How to Barbecue a 5-Pound Boneless Turkey Breast

A 5-pound boneless turkey breast takes 40 to 60 minutes over covered indirect heat, followed by 8 to 10 minutes over the hot side of the grill to brown it. The reliable approach is a two-zone grill setup: roast the breast away from the flame first, then finish it briefly over direct heat. Use a meat thermometer throughout; timing helps you plan, but the internal temperature decides when the turkey is ready.

Situation Typical Range Why
Covered indirect roast 40 to 60 minutes, until 150°F Gently cooks the thick center without scorching the outside
Direct-heat finish 2 to 2½ minutes per side, 8 to 10 minutes total, until 165°F Browns the surface and finishes the turkey safely
Rest before slicing 20 minutes Lets the meat settle before carving

What Makes Boneless Turkey Breast Different on the Grill

A boneless breast cooks faster and more unevenly than a whole turkey because it has no bones to slow the transfer of heat. It is also easy to dry out if it stays over direct heat for the entire cook.

The solution is indirect grilling. On a gas grill, that means leaving one burner on and placing the turkey over the burners that are off. On a charcoal grill, it means putting the lit coals on one side and the turkey on the opposite side.

A compact, evenly shaped roast is especially helpful. Some 5-pound boneless breasts are sold as one tied roast, while others are two breast halves that need to be stacked and tied together before grilling. Either form works, but the turkey should be secure enough to turn without separating.

How to Barbecue a 5-Pound Boneless Turkey Breast

Season, tie, grill-roast indirectly, brown, and rest the turkey until its thickest part reaches 165°F.

Step 1: Season and Shape the Turkey Breast

  1. Start with a fully thawed boneless turkey breast. Pat it dry with paper towels so the oil and seasoning can cling to the surface.
  2. If you are working with two boneless breast halves, season the exposed meat with 4 teaspoons kosher salt or 2 teaspoons table salt total. Check whether your salt is kosher or table salt before measuring; the same spoonful of table salt is much saltier than kosher salt.
  3. Add black pepper and any dry herbs or rub you like. Use a light coating of oil to help the seasonings adhere and to encourage browning.
  4. Stack the halves with one cut side facing up and the other facing down, placing the thick end over the tapered end. This creates a roast with a more even thickness.
  5. Tie the roast with one 36-inch piece of kitchen twine running lengthwise, then add 5 to 7 crosswise pieces at 1-inch intervals. A tied, stacked roast holds its shape and cooks more evenly on the grill, as in the National Turkey Federation grill-roast method.
  6. If the breast has skin, carefully remove it before seasoning, reserve it, then drape it back over the assembled roast and tuck the ends underneath. If you have a single compact boneless roast that is already tied, leave it intact rather than trying to reshape it.
  7. Refrigerate a newly tied roast uncovered for 1 hour before grilling. This helps the outside dry slightly so it browns more effectively.

Step 2: Build a Two-Zone Grill

  1. For a gas grill, preheat all burners on high with the lid closed for about 15 minutes. Clean and lightly oil the grates. Leave one primary burner on high, then turn the other burner or burners off. The turkey will cook over the unlit side.
  2. For a charcoal grill, fill a large chimney starter with 6 quarts of charcoal, or about 100 briquettes. Chimney capacity and grill size vary, so confirm what your chimney starter and grill can safely hold. Light the charcoal and wait about 20 minutes, until the coals are fully ignited and partly covered with a thin layer of ash.
  3. Arrange all the charcoal on one half of the grill, leaving the other half clear. Set the cooking grate in place, clean it, and lightly oil it.

Keep the lid closed during the indirect stage so the grill works like an outdoor oven.

Step 3: Grill-Roast Over Indirect Heat

  1. Place the turkey breast on the cooler side of the grill, with the thickest part facing away from the strongest heat.
  2. Close the lid and roast until an instant-read thermometer inserted into the thickest part reaches 150°F. Expect this stage to take 40 to 60 minutes.
  3. Halfway through the indirect cook, rotate the roast 180 degrees. Do not flip it onto the hot side yet; the rotation simply evens out the heat exposure.
  4. Keep the lid closed as much as possible. Frequent checking dumps heat from the grill and lengthens the roast.

Step 4: Finish Over the Hot Side

  1. When the turkey reaches 150°F, slide it to the hot side of the grill.
  2. Leave the lid open and brown the roast for 2 to 2½ minutes per side, or 8 to 10 minutes total. Turn it carefully to brown all exposed sides without tearing the skin or loosening the twine.
  3. After the hot-side finish, check the thickest part again. The turkey is ready to remove from the grill when it reaches 165°F.

If the turkey is brown but has not reached the finishing temperature, move it back to the cooler side, close the lid, and continue cooking until the center is done.

Step 5: Rest, Carve, and Serve

  1. Transfer the turkey to a clean cutting board or platter.
  2. Rest it for 20 minutes before carving. Do not tent it tightly enough to trap steam, which can soften a crisp exterior.
  3. Remove the twine as you slice. Cut the breast across the grain into slices about 1/2 inch thick.
  4. Serve immediately, or arrange the slices on a warm platter with any accumulated juices spooned over the top.

Skin and Brine Choices for Turkey Breast

Use the skin arrangement that fits the cooking route rather than assuming that a boneless breast cooks the same with skin on and skin off.

For a grill-roasted turkey breast assembled from two halves, reserving and draping the skin over the roast helps protect the meat during the covered portion of the cook. The direct-heat finish then browns and crisps that skin.

A smoker setup can be different. For smoking, remove the skin before seasoning if you want the smoke and rub directly on the meat rather than trying to crisp skin in a low-heat environment.

A pre-brined turkey breast needs only a light oil coating and dry rub before smoking. The measured salt preparation is for an unbrined breast, so avoid adding that full salt amount to a turkey labeled as pre-brined, enhanced, or already seasoned.

How to Confirm the Turkey Is Ready

The outside can look deeply browned while the center is still underdone, especially with a thick, rolled breast. The thermometer is the confirmation tool, not the color of the meat or the clarity of the juices.

Before taking the turkey off the grill, confirm that the thickest part has reached 165°F. If the roast has an especially thick end and a tapered end, make an additional temperature check in the thick area. Avoid measuring in a pocket beside twine or in a thin edge, which can give a misleadingly high reading.

A finished breast should have a browned exterior, feel firm rather than squishy, and stay intact when moved with tongs or a spatula. After resting, slice one end first to check that the meat is evenly cooked before carving the whole roast.

Frequently Asked Questions

Should I Smoke a Turkey Breast With the Skin On or Off?

Remove the skin for a smoking setup if you want the rub and smoke to reach the meat directly. For a grill-roasted boneless breast, keeping the skin and draping it over the tied roast helps shield the meat during indirect cooking and gives you something to crisp over the hot side.

Is It Better to Smoke a Turkey Breast at 225°F or 250°F?

For this grill-roasting method, use a two-zone grill setup. The turkey is ready when the thickest part reaches 165°F.

Can I Barbecue a Pre-Brined Boneless Turkey Breast?

Yes. Use a light oil coating and a dry rub rather than adding a full salt seasoning to a breast that has already been brined. Pre-brined turkey can become overly salty if it receives the same salt treatment as an unbrined roast.

Do I Need to Tie a Boneless Turkey Breast?

A single compact roast usually does not need additional tying. Tie two loose breast halves into one roast with one 36-inch piece of twine lengthwise and 5 to 7 crosswise ties spaced 1 inch apart so they stay together while turning on the grill.

How do you keep a boneless turkey breast from drying out on the grill, and should you keep the lid closed?

Keep the grill lid closed while the breast cooks on the cooler side until its thickest area reaches 150°F. Then move it over the hot side and brown it uncovered for 2 to 2½ minutes per side. Remove the turkey when the thickest part reaches 165°F.